The practice of mental illness diagnosis has long been less than scientific, as few biological markers have been identified for any of the mental illnesses. This month, a study published in the academic journal Biological Psychiatry states that a simple eye movement test can detect schizophrenia, and with an astonishing 98% accuracy.
The eye tests include having a person track a slow-moving object, hold their gaze on a fixed object, and look at common scenes—‘free viewing.’ In the first test, people with schizophrenia demonstrate a deficit in that their eye movements fall behind in tracking the object, and then catch up with a sudden eye movement. People without schizophrenia are able to track smoothly, in comparison. For the fixed-object test, people with schizophrenia have a less steady gaze than people without, and on the final test, free viewing, those with the illness display atypical scanning patterns compared to data for ‘normal eye movement.’
I found it interesting that there was no difference in test results for people with schizophrenia who were on medication versus those who were medication free.
The authors of this study are recommending that the eye tests be used as a supplement to the existing symptom-based diagnoses method. In addition to providing a biological marker for the diagnosis of schizophrenia, the tests are quick, inexpensive and can be administered by a medical assistant or a first-line physician (general practitioner).
It also struck me that these tests could be effective for those people who have paranoia as a primary symptom and therefore don’t respond well when asked a bunch of personal questions (as a diagnostic approach). Back in 2000, my mum was in the hospital for a minor surgery and so her doctor arranged for a psychiatric team to visit her. When they started asking questions, she became suspicious and irritated and pulled the bed sheet up over her head. With eye tests, a clinician could potentially gather information without having the subject feel like they’re being interrogated and clam up.
Here’s a link to the entire journal article: Simple Viewing Tests Can Detect Eye Movement Abnormalities That Distinguish Schizophrenia Cases from Controls with Exceptional Accuracy.
Are you aware of any other tests that provide biological markers for mental illnesses? Please share your information on this fascinating topic!
Hopefully discovering what causes their eye movements to be different will lead to more understanding about this horrible disease. It certainly is a simple test, both for the patients and the doctors. Very interesting and thank you for publishing this. Someday, I’d like to understand what happened to my mother, and I know you would too.
We can hope, hey, Mary? Because our mothers were really robbed of their lives, and so if this helps with earlier detection, then it’s very good news. I’ve read that if someone is treated right at their first psychotic break, they have a better chance of recovery and remission. And I’m not sure if they’re studying *why* a person with schizophrenia has these different eye movements, but I sure hope they are. It would be a good next step to uncover more knowledge about the illness.
My goodness, what a beautifully simple yet accurate test! I’m sure that if it becomes a standard, routine test it will help so many people. I’m always astonished by medical developments of this kind and it just reinforces my conviction that we still have so much to learn in healthcare. When we are old, we will look back and wonder how we survived what we now regard as up-to-the-minute research and technology! Thank you for telling us about this, Laura.
Best wishes
Debbie
Indeed, still so much to learn in healthcare, and especially when it comes to the brain. Thanks for your comment, Debbie.
The study is Interesting and hopefully it can yield a simple test to diagnose schizophrenia. There is one caveat though. The researchers used healthy individual as controls in these experiments. Telling whether a patient has schizophrenia when compared to a healthy individual is much easier than telling whether a patient has schizophrenia compared to another patient that has a related mental illness that requires a different treatment. And this is the real test of these methods: whether they can discriminate between several related conditions. The hope is that their method will allow them to achieve that fine tuning especially if they combine them with preexisting methods. Thanks for sharing Laura.
You always raise such good points, Rolando. That’s very true, because often it’s evident right off the bat that there’s a mental illness present, it’s figuring out which one so that treatment can be tailored. Testing across groups with other illnesses would add a lot of granularity to the results. Thanks for your comment.
It would be great if the test does prove useful over the long term. Hopefully more biological markers for mental illness can continue to be found. Early-on in her disease, my mother was diagnosed with various mental illnesses before it was decided she was bipolar, but that was over 35 years ago, so I would hope diagnosis is more efficient and accurate now. Any advance in testing can only be a good thing.
There seems to be so much crossover between the different mental illnesses. Biological markers would definitely help sort things out so people don’t have to go through what your mom did, with various diagnoses.
This is extremely interesting. However, I wonder if that 98% accuracy also includes a boatload of false positives, because it seems like there could be any number of reasons a person could have difficulty smoothly tracking an object with their eyes, such as nerve damage or some other kind of neurological disorder. I guess I’ll have to read the full article and see! Thanks for the share.
Hi Jared, you make a good point, and I’m sure there would be at least some false positives in there. I believe they do talk about the models they used in order to establish that their numbers were accurate. Thanks for reading and I’m also glad to learn about your site.
This is a very interesting article. 98% accuracy is a pretty impressive statistic. I’d like to see this in action.
Hi Lawrence, thanks for your comment, and yes, the accuracy number in the study is so good that it would be helpful to revisit these numbers after it has been in clinical use for a while.
No, I really don’t remember any case you discussed above but this is the example of technology that how our technology is advancing day by day . Thanks for sharing.
It is indeed, Sahil. Thank you for reading!